Kent Hartman’s book The Wrecking Crew is one of those books I’d heard a lot about and had been meaning to read for a long time. Well, I finally got off my duff and read it, and I’m glad I did. The book is about the dirty little secret of 1960’s music industry wherein a group of ultra-talent studio musicians secretly played on a great majority of rock ‘n roll records. This group, known as The Wrecking Crew, was not credited on the liner notes of the records they played. Thus, the public was none the wiser that it wasn’t their favorite band playing on their records.
The Monkees are a well-known example of a band that used The Wrecking Crew. People perhaps unfairly give The Monkees a hard time because they weren’t playing their own instruments. Well it turns out, there was a lot of that going around in the 1960’s. Bands you might not expect, like The Byrds, used The Wrecking Crew. Record labels had two motivations for using The Wrecking Crew over the actual bands, although really both reasons just come down to money.
The first reason a separate band was used due to simple logistics. Bands out on tour would have to stop touring in order to venture back into the studio and record. The Wrecking Crew acted as the recording band, while the band the band’s public face remained on the road. Secondly, The Wrecking Crew, and musicians like them, were used because a majority of rockers couldn’t play their instruments very well. At the time, record companies looked down on rock music, and didn’t understand it. They treated rock recordings like they did jazz or classical music and thought the recordings should be perfect. Hence, The Wrecking Crew was brought in.
Hartman’s book focuses on a handful of Wrecking Crew musicians, chiefly the more famous members like drummer Hal Blaine, Carol Kaye, Leon Russell, and Glen Campbell. I was really surprised to find out that Glen “Rhinestone Cowboy” Campbell was a highly respected guitarist prior to hitting it big with his solo career. I knew he’d essentially joined The Beach Boys touring band, but I had no idea he played on most of the top hits for the 1960’s. The Wrecking Crew were all over the radio, playing on hits by diverse acts such as The Mamas & The Papas, Frank Sinatra, The Beach Boys, Dean Martin, Sonny & Cher, Simon & Garfunkel, and The Byrds.
It’s unnerving how the Wrecking Crew, while highly paid, weren’t credited for playing on the records they worked on. Had I been writing about music at the time (as a fan), I would have foolishly thought The Monkees were playing their own instruments. As I read the book, I kept waiting for the public to find out and become outraged, but that never happened. Instead, what ended up happening was that as rock evolved a more authentic, rough sound was prized making the technically superior Wrecking Crew unneeded. The Beatles also had something to do with the demise of the practice of studio musicians subbing for the actual band. After the Fab Four hit it big, most bands wanted to write and play your own instruments.
The Wrecking Crew is an interesting read but I found the structure of the book somewhat clumsy. Rather use a straight chronological framework Hartman jumps back and forth through time. The chapters themselves follow a chronology, but within each one Hartman tends of pick a player and give us his back story, which often gives us information we either already know or will be told again in another chapter. It’s a little nit-pick, but I guess I would have preferred one chapter where we just got everyone’s backstory out-of-the-way, then moved on with the various recordings. Also, the Wrecking Crew was a pretty large group of people, but the book really only focuses on a few, which was a little disappointing. I realize not everyone is going to be as interested in the Wrecking Crew’s trumpet players than say, their drummers, but I would have liked a little more diversity in the band members as the book is mainly about guitarists and drummers.
I found it interesting how collaborative the recording process was as time and again members of the Wrecking Crew wound up actually contributing to the writing of songs as well as playing. I was really surprised when this happened in the chapter devoted to the recording of Simon & Garfunkel’s BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER album. I still can’t believe that such talented, famous artists would allow regular working-musicians to tinker with their albums. But time and again Hartman shows us that The Wrecking Crew were more than just musicians, they were the best hired guns in the business.
The book recounts some really interesting nuggets of rock trivia, and is chock-full of juicy insider tidbits. Most of the really interesting chapters revolve around producer Phil Spector and Brian Wilson, two titans of the studio who really used The Wrecking Crew to their full potential. The Wrecking Crew is brimming with really interesting anecdotes. Some of my favorite from the book are:
- Leon Russell getting pulled over in his new Cadillac by the LAPD and being told to get a “real” job (he was making way more than the cop).
- Phil Spector’s bodyguards using hand signals to let an angry musician know that Phil had a gun in the studio.
- Unsure how to end “Layla” Eric Clapton overheard drummer Jim Gordon noodling on the piano and decided to use the drummer’s mini-composition to close out the song. Gordon later when nuts and murdered his mom—that’s write, the guy playing piano at the end of “Layla” stabbed his mother to death.
I highly recommend The Wrecking Crew to anyone with even a passing interest in early rock music and the music business of the 1960’s. The book’s a nice, quick read and would make a great gift for any music fan.
Didn’t know about this one at all. Looks really interesting!
It’s a good read and I hear the author optioned it into a movie. Not surprising because as I was reading the book I kept thinking “why hasn’t someone made this into a movie?”